The Supreme Court has rejected a challenge to President Trump’s plan to exclude illegal immigrants from the count used to allocate seats in congress to states based on population.
The constitution requires only that there be a count of “the whole number of persons” in the United States every 10 years.
According to NPR:
The U.S. Supreme Court dodged a ruling on whether President Trump can exclude undocumented immigrants from a key census count. The opinion said the case was “riddled with contingencies and speculation that impede judicial review.”
“At the end of the day, the standing and ripeness inquiries both lead to the conclusion that judicial resolution of this” case is “premature,” the justices wrote.
The decision leaves open the possibility for Trump to try to remove some undocumented immigrants from a key census count, but immigrant rights advocates warned Friday that they would sue.
“If the Administration actually tries to implement this policy, we’ll sue. Again. And we’ll win,” Dale Ho, director of the American Civil Liberties Union’s voting rights project, said on Twitter.
President Trump issued an executive memorandum in July directing the Census Bureau to send him two sets of numbers. One containing the whole number of persons and the other showing the population when illegal immigrants were subtracted.
Is there any part of our judicial system that is NOT part of the Deep State ?
Apparently NOT!
time for some surgical removing
Maybe a little overdue.
Got that right! Don’t just eliminate them from the count, throw ALL the illegals completely out of our country!…NOW!
Return all the illegal criminal invader voters to the mid east schitt holes where globalists and globalist puppet $oro$ and globalist puppet barry soetoro transported them from .
Careful now…… you apparently do not remember how PISSED King Barrack from Kenya got when Trump said Africa was a shit hole! And most of the mid east is technically in AFRICA!!!!
The illegal criminal invader voters are primarily from the Americas.
Remove all illegals now.
2020 Election Investigative Documentary: Who’s Stealing America?
https://www.theepochtimes.com/2020-election-investigation-who-is-stealing-america_3617562.html
I agree hang all tyrants
Some surgical removing like when they removed the gonads from libby snow flake males and implanted the gonads on libby snow flake females, surgical removing . . . . .
Butcher them?
Is there any part of our government that is NOT part of the deep state. Even the executive branch has it’s share. With Biden in office our whole government will be controlled by the deep state.
Or worse Soros the Nazi collaborator.
globalist puppet barry soetoro sold all the voter machines to globalist puppet $oro$ so that globalist puppet $oro$ can manipulate the voter machines to appoint globalist puppet democrat criminal party and globalist puppet rino criminal party .
80+% of Americans are Deep State.
Doesn’t look that way…
NO
Sadly, the Deep State is pretty old and their stuck in their old way. Biden is not a good thing for this country. Especially now. Biden could be the destruction of America. Why do the people know and the politician’s not see it. See, China acting up along with Russia and yet nothing. Joe Biden is owned by China. His son, Hunter, made sure of that.
All the globalists and globalist puppet $oro$, puppet democrat criminal party and puppet rino criminal party and globalist media and puppet supreme court love globalists and globalist puppet $oro$ bribes to preach all the globalist agendas .
What is this Deep State thing?
Is that anyone who does not accept Donald J. Trump as their personal savior?
Nope. The deep state has been here long before Trump. It is composed of unelected bureaucrats and super rich people who are in league with elected socialist office holders. Funny all the super rich push socialism when they have profited so much from capitalism.
NO!
The Deep State is comprised of 80+% of Americans.
Get these 3rd world illegal criminals out of our country, or we will bankrupt our great country.
MAGA 2020
It is already bankrupt. We didn’t have 5 trillion dollars to spend, this year, we were already 24 Trillion in debt. What makes anyone think we are not already bankrupt?
We need Mitch Rapp.
Send “Rapp” to see Swallowwell first!
illegal aliens are illegal.
they do not exist in the legal world and you have to stop forcing Americans to pay their way.
WE must stop their invasions! Trump has been tirelessly to shore up America’s borders. The Dimocrats have been working to tear down everything that makes us a sovereign nation. Which is exactly why they are desperate to get rid of Trump.
Illegals spend more time working than White Trash.
To the aclu in the words of the immortal reprobate Lori stink foot I have two words for you the first word begins with an F and the second word is you
And millions will second that motion! As long as there is no physical contact with that awful thing.
And even more millions do not.
It’s pretty bad when the supreme court cannot do the right thing.
They’re beginning to sound like, and look like, brand new employees of Geo. Soros.
The Supremes now represent the finest justice money,and fear can buy,just not in the best interest of the American{U.S.A.} people. A moral coward leads the court at this time.Typical “Bushie”,lies to your face,and stabs you in the back. Get covid19 soon Roberts!
Regarding Roberts, apparently he’s the reason the Supreme court refused to hear the Texas suit earlier this week. A law clerk, who will remain nameless, overheard a heated debate by the honorables behind closed doors. Justice Thomas was citing the precedent (and merits) of the Gore/Bush case years ago and sounded in favor of taking it on. Roberts, the head justice, was heard screaming in reply “f**k the Gore/Bush case, they DIDN’T HAVE RIOTS BACK THEN”.
Sooo, he’s a spineless coward so afraid of the domestic terrorists that he’s letting them win. Looks like from the “Greatest Generation” of only a few decades ago, we’ve sunk to being the wimpiest. God help America!
Wouldn’t surprise me if Roberts has a few skeletons somewhere in his closet that the liberals know about.
A trip or two to pedophile island. At least his name is on flight logs.
Anyone who does not accept Donald J. Trump as their personal savior is spineless.
And globalists and globalist puppet $oro$ own all the money in the world .
Trump does not have enough money to buy the Supremes.
You can thank Obama for putting lesbian women on it! We will win! Alabama is sending Tommy Tubberville, and he will vote against the “Electoral College”!
2020 Election Investigative Documentary: Who’s Stealing America?
https://www.theepochtimes.com/2020-election-investigation-who-is-stealing-america_3617562.html
That’s good to know!!!!
Please watch this documentary from The Epoch Times and share it with everyone in your contact list.
2020 Election Investigative Documentary: Who’s Stealing America?
https://www.theepochtimes.com/2020-election-investigation-who-is-stealing-america_3617562.html
globalists and globalist puppet $oro$ puppet, supreme court love globalists and globalist puppet $oro$ bribes to preach the globalist agendas .
It’s pretty bad when 6 of the Justices were appointed by Republicans, 3 of them by Trump.
They must think that Trump is a real jerk .
So, what exactly is the purpose of us paying these political activists in black robes?
AND THE SUPOSEDLY LAST ” HERORIC ” GROUP HAS RUN FOR THE HILLS AGAIN AND NO DOUBT ARE NOTHING BUT ” EXTORSONIST EMPLOYEES ” BEING PAID TO HIDE WHEN THE ROAD TURNS TO GRAVEL!
Regarding the threatened suit and “we’ll win”, will they?
2020 Election Investigative Documentary: Who’s Stealing America?
https://www.theepochtimes.com/2020-election-investigation-who-is-stealing-america_3617562.html
Get rid of Roberts because he is an evil influence on that SC and I believe he will be stepping down bevause of scandal!
Please watch the documentary from The Epoch Times and share it.
2020 Election Investigative Documentary: Who’s Stealing America?
https://www.theepochtimes.com/2020-election-investigation-who-is-stealing-america_3617562.html
What is new in this World when the President of this USA tries to violate the Constitution that has held this USA together for over 200 Years. When the Constitution say that the census was to count ALL persons in this USA, and being that so many were here illegally, if that bothered the Founders I do think they would have mentioned it in that Constitution.
It is only prejudice and hateful persons who would deny other s better life. This much the same as was done to the Irish in 1850 when they came to this USA, and most of them came legally.
When America Despised the Irish: The 19th Century’s Refugee Crisis – HISTORY
exactly why at the time shortly after the entire New York police force was Irish, and the “Gangs of New York”, is based on the same time period.
you are an idiot ! Our founders never thought we would be so stupid as to let 3rd world ignorant in to our nation
DITTO !
When our nation was founded we were a third world nation.
We imported slaves and euthanized the native population.
Come in legally like my Mother did
How long did your mom stand in line of her visa?
Keep on eating your globalist pills roberta and maybe one day something will sprout and you can stop to “imagine” robert .
God is a globalist..
Next the globalists and globalist puppet $oro$ and globalist puppet democrat criminal party and globalist puppet rino criminal party and globalist media will be sending mail in ballots to every country and allowing every other country to “appoint” our globalist puppet politicians .
The dems spat all over the constitution during our last vote for president. and you are actually trying to act upset about this ?
SOOO, if I am reading all this correctly, in advance of an election, those in charge could move large groups of ILLEGALS from one area, to another, which can result in a different area getting more representation, because of a higher census count………..BULLSHIT..and then the brain deads on the Supreme Court don’t even want to consider this BULLSHIT? My opinion
Where did this happen?
Those who wrote the term “persons” in 1787 never anticipated anything as insidious as illegal aliens. Bills repeatedly have been submitted to amend the Constitution by replacing the term “persons” with “citizens.” It’s a colossal gift from the GOP to the democrats. A remedy to this unearned gift is needed and failure to amend the Constitution punishes every taxpayer.
Those who wrote the term “persons” in 1787 never anticipated anything as insidious as slavery.
If they are undocumented, how were they able to vote?? The corruption against the president is reaching new levels
Simple Illegally
Fewer than .1% of the illegals voted.
Why the F*** would illegals be counted in the 1st place? The dumbest thing I have heard regarding the Census… it is designed to capture the number of Citizens!
Our Founding Fathers were very clear.
The Census was designed to ‘capture’ the number of Persons.
Depending on status some persons were counted as being 3/5 of a human.
impeach Roberts..he has sold our country out repeatedly and is unfit for the court
That was clear the first time he made his First bad decision.
I worked for INS before it was divided into 3 agencies after 9/11.
There was clarity in the rules for enforcement of law.
There was clarity about voting requirements. No one other than a CITIZEN could vote LEGALLY!
To do so was a felony and would end with being removed from the country.
After the enforcement element of Last Amnesty Legislation failed to be enforced because of backlash of businesses and other special interest groups gained the power to control that agency, the slippery slope of failure to enforce excelled—until PRESIDENT TRUMP!
If the radical Socialist Movement is not defeated all those gains in realizing our secure border will be defeated.
Just Roberts?
What about the Trump appointees?
The people need to stand and speak in front of the supreme court and be heard, for the justices to do their job that’s why they were sworn in the first place!!! to review what is presented…to them and support the constitution, the people…of the Unites States of America..
Please; honor your job, that’s why you were put their in the first place…easy to look the other way….their are words for people like you….shame!
thank you,
a citizen of the great america
The only one above the supreme court is GOD . The ones under them have no balls.
god is too busy blessing; globalists and globalist puppet $oro$ and globalist puppet democrat criminal party and globalist puppet rino criminal party and globalist puppet fbi criminal organisation and globalist media and globalist puppet, libby snow flake looters/rioters/arsonists/etc AND altar boy raping priests .
The devil is not god and that is who is behind S0R0s and the globalist NWO agenda (preparing for the Antichrist). The Catholics involved in pedophilia are Jesuits. They do not accept Jesus of Nazareth as their Messiah, they are in the occult, hence all the wickedness. The current Pope just happens to be Jesuit! Don’t put their evil at God’s feet, if they don’t repent and turn from their wicked ways and receive Jesus of Nazareth as their Lord and Savior, hell is their destination, forever. (Vengeance is Mine says The Lord, I will repay.) Make no mistake, they will be held accountable one way or another. Trump is a man and doing very well fighting these corrupt devils, but he does have God’s help. This battle isn’t over!! #MAGA
2020 Election Investigative Documentary: Who’s Stealing America?
https://www.theepochtimes.com/2020-election-investigation-who-is-stealing-america_3617562.html
AMEN.
Stand back and take a good look at what’s happening today in the USA. That’s what Communism looks like. Government controls every thing and everybody.Example the Covid-19 dictates for your personal life. Kissing boot tops are next. Got your papers.?
Communism all around the globe equals globalism .
Immigrants don’t have rights unless they’ve come here through legitimate means. It’s time that our government adheres to this and stop illegal immigrants from coming here by completing the border, not recognizing illegals as citizens in our census and thereby not allowing states that harbor these illegals to have more electoral votes, and by not allowing states to give illegals monetary support. I bet those immigrants that have come here through legal means and become citizens would agree with this.
2020 Election Investigative Documentary: Who’s Stealing America?
https://www.theepochtimes.com/2020-election-investigation-who-is-stealing-america_3617562.html
We have laws let us them
Watch this documentary!!!! We cannot give up. Biden did NOT win this election!!!
2020 Election Investigative Documentary: Who’s Stealing America?
https://www.theepochtimes.com/2020-election-investigation-who-is-stealing-america_3617562.html
Not necessarily evident in this ruling, but this follows logically from the TX case against the several swing states suffering from extraordinary voter and counting fraud. In that case, the SCOTUS declined to even hear that case. An “ear-witness” advised viewers on NEWSMAX that he heard the discussions from outside the room, and the Chief Justice shouted that the 2010 case in Florida DIDN’T HAVE RIOTING going on. In other words, the decision to not hear the case was to avoid a decision that may spark a riot, so the court failed to do their duty in order to pacify the Democrats. In other words, we DON’T HAVE A SCOTUS any more. Remember when Schumer shouted a warning to the court members that they would be held to account if they voted against Schumer’s position? Chief Justice remembers.
What’s wrong with the can’t stupid out of stuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuupidity with these Supreme Court rats. Americans RULE. Pretty bad your Justice Robert’s is on a picture frolicking in water with Bill Clinton on EPSTEIN ISLAND. WE THE PEOPLE WANT JUSTICE FOR THE VOTER FRAUD. HUNTER BIDEN/JOE BIDEN, BULLSHIT. QUIT THE PUSSYFOOTING AROUND. IF YOU ELECTED OFFICIALS CAN’T DO YOUR JOBS. WELL AMERICAN’S CAN AND WILL. HAD ENOUGH LIES, CHEATING,CORRUPTION, FAKE RUSSIAN HOAX, IMPEACHMENT,FAKE MEDIA’S WITH DIARRHEA OF THERE ROTTEN SHITTY MOUTHS,TECHS. WE THE AMERICAN PEOPLE AREN’T GIVING UP THE TRUE PRESIDENT. WHICH IS AND WAS ALL ALONG DONALD J. TRUMP. MILLIONS OF US. GOD BLESS AMERICA AND IN GOD WE TRUST AMEN 🙏
The Dems want their vote. Dems give them free everything,and we the real tax paying citizens pay for it…..
Hard working tax paying AMERICANS can’t afford to pay when they are not allowed to go to work and not allowed to open their businesses etc .
Roberts is nothing more than a scared little wussy. He is so afraid of the leftist thugs that he is just a worthless coward.
I wonder what they have in him?!
When the the Dems can steal the election right before the eyes of the whole world and get away with it we are doomed….
Pelosi won’t remove Swalwell because it would disturb her Chinese communist business masters.
WOW just WOW 😳, where is the justice??
Well, I guess we could go back to the 3/5 count. The only reason why I can see them being counted is to keep track of them – as illegals – and if States want to share their portion of the “big pie” that is alloted, then that’s up to them & their citizens.
why do illeglas have any rights other than a trip back over the border of course Biden will destroy this country by throwing open borders and providing more benefits to them than its own citizens Of course he will never miss a payday he will get his presidential salary, which I guarantee he will take as well as congressional retirement and vice-president salary. Oh and lets not forget his payments from the Chinese. After he goes to take a knee in Iran he will certainly get recompensed.
They committed a crime by coming here illegally. They get welfare and food stamps, free medical, free education and housing. Some that meet the age requirement get Social Security without ever paying a dime into the system. I don’t care how Liberals try to justify it, that is stealing. Stealing is a crime. Many are even voting. The Democrats have been working over time to make a liar out of who ever said; Crime doesn’t pay.” It pays big time for the undocumented aliens.
No illegals on the census, plain and simple, if your not a citizen, u don’t get counted,what’s so dam hard about that. Two different counts, to let us know, all legal citizens, and the 30 million illegals, that shouldn’t be counted, not 11 million, that count was from 20 yrs ago, get it right.
The demoncRATs are determined to keep on until they are all removed from the government!!!!!!
we need a meeting of the minds. The Mayflower Compact’s 400 year Covenant with God is up for renewal on November 11, 2020. Nov 3, 2020 will determine if it is breached. The Gun control issue with the DNC / CCP will be used to attack former Trump supporters if he loses do to voter fraud. If so expect a Bolshevik style purge of the American opposition to the NWO. Just like the 1919 Russian Bolshevik movement, below. Attached is Clinton’s Weekly Reader and a1919 Bolshevik Poster demanding “Citizens Turn in weapons” they then rounded up those the Bolsheviks considered divergent and murdered 22 million. Think if these DNC/CCP/ ANTIFA, BLM TAKE POWER and we have lost our favor as a nation with God, what kind of hellacious treason the DNC Marxist will inflict. Hussein Obama packed the military with treasonous Asses, the FBI was handing out Qurans like at UAH under Obama; see attached. There has never been a more important to draw closer to God, and support our President, our Country and our God. ANTIFA in manifesto instruction targets white males. If anyone wants a copy to read, please advise. Mike
The Supreme Court should be thoroughly ashamed of themselves, especially Justice Roberts who is a coward.
CHINA not only is killing us with its biological Virus Weapon, it is endeavoring to enslave us through our corrupt Politicians and Billionaires. They are greedy bastards who craves money and power more than they love us or God.
For future election security we need to reregister with the part of our choice, but fill out our ID Cards with full name and address, current address, and date of registration. On back of Card in square place their thumb print. The original is sent to the National ID Voter Data Base. A copy is given to the voter. When voting each ballot has a square on it where you place your thumb print. When inserted into the vote counting machine then thumb print is compared to the one in the data base. If it matches, then the current date is recorded and the vote counts. If it does not match, the date is recorded and a security guard removes the ballot and takes the voter into temporary custody to ascertain whether there was a mistake, error, or was an attempt made to illegally vote. If Guilty the cheater is jailed and will be booked as a criminal and prosecuted. No one can vote either in person or by mail in multiple times or for someone else. They will get caught and sent to prison!
Since the BEAST (the Mouth Piece of Lucifer) the News Media, and the Democrats are all in bed with the Communist in China, why not deport all of them? Deport ABC,CBS, NBC, CNN, MSNBC, FB, Twitter, Google, Amazon, Microsoft, Apple, Disney, and any other who want to move to China. Deport all of them as undesirables. Their money is invested there, their loyalty is with them. We will allow Fox News, and a few other loyal news sources to remain. We will help finance our energy companies and small businesses who do love and respect us to stay. Other companies will leap into the vacated positions these traitors occupied and in no time at all we will be greater than we were before. With Trump leading us our poor people will become wealthy folks and our small businesses will become large successful businesses. We don’t need largen greedy companies that are not loyal to their home country. All of these companies, and many more, deserted us for China, and are not American any more. They are traitors. They abandoned us and attacked Trump for wanting to Make America Great Again. That means they do not want to make America great. They just want to become $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ TRILLIONAIRES $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ instead of mere $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ BILLIONAIRES $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ the greedy un-loyal bastards! Face facts they are gobbling up all of our small businesses using this pandemic shut down. When it is over they will be your only source of service. No competition! China and those greedy bastards will own us!
Playing games.
I’ve been calling for a NEW CENSUS for a while now. My reasoning behind this is that I’m a victim of the California, Washington and Oregon people who filled out their census long before they flocked from their burnt, looted non cities to my State of Arizona! Point being, we are now underrepresented and all the blue states are now OVER-REPRESENTED! This is just wrong, we’re supposed to wait another 10 years for more lies? F/U swamp creatures! GTFO!
I think Trump should have ran for President in 2008. It seems he is being overcome by the deepness of this swamp, but I know God is helping him. Interesting that Kavanaugh and Amy are siding with Leftists and globalist Roberts SCOTUS Justices. Both are Catholic, is that why? Any ideas?
The pick and choose notions of the Supreme Court is irritating to say the least. If you don’t have an opinion, then why are you there exactly?
I had hopes that we might actually see some Constitutional justice with this court, but they are as gutless and corrupt as any court in my lifetime. Illegals don’t have rights above legal citizens, but they are siding with the liberal communist that have infiltrated the government. Nikita Khrushchev was right when he said that the American people would let themselves be subverted by communism without a fight. What a sad state of affairs. Now the very judges who were appointed to uphold the Constitution are helping trash it. The rights of illegals ends with the protection from personal harm and the theft of their property. No where does the Constitution guarantee them the right to change the country unless they become citizens and lawfully vote to do so. No where in my copy of the Constitution can I find where the illegals have the same or more rights as legal citizens. Go to any other nation illegally and see just how many rights you have. None is the answer.