Justice Thomas Goes After Big Tech for Censorship, Says SCOTUS Will Be Forced to Rule on Their Power

U.S. Department of Agriculture, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

In Justice Clarence Thomas’s concurring opinion the conservatively leaning Supreme Court member said that soon they will be forced to rule on the role big tech platforms play with regard to the First Amendment. On Monday, the Supreme Court voted to dismiss a case against Trump which argued he violated the First Amendment by blocking some of his critics on Twitter.

Fox News reports:

Thomas noted that while Trump had the power to block other users, Twitter was then able to block “all Twitter users from interacting with his messages” by banning his account altogether.

“Because unbridled control of the account resided in the hands of a private party, First Amendment doctrine may not have applied to respondents’ complaint of stifled speech,” Thomas pointed out, stating that “[w]hether governmental use of private space implicates the First Amendment often depends on the government’s control over that space.”

Thomas acknowledged how modern technology is not always easily addressed by existing legal doctires, and warned that the Supreme Court “will soon have no choice but to address how our legal doctrines apply to highly concentrated, privately owned information infrastructure such as digital platforms.”

“The Second Circuit feared that then-President Trump cut off speech by using the features that Twitter made available to him,” Thomas said. “But if the aim is to ensure that speech is not smothered, then the more glaring concern must perforce be the dominant digital platforms themselves. As Twitter made clear, the right to cut off speech lies most powerfully in the hands of private digital platforms. The extent to which that power matters for purposes of the First Amendment and the extent to which that power could lawfully be modified raise interesting and important questions.”

Republican lawmakers have been fierce critics of Big Tech even before Trump was banned from multiple platforms in January and have called for sweeping legislative changes to protect users.



  1. SCOTUS better start doing their job, someone needs to tell Roberts, he is compromised!!!
    I wonder what his skeletons are???

    1. SCOTUS cannot legislate from the bench. Twitter. Face Book and Google now have a monopoly and it should be broken up and amended. .The Sherman- Clayton Anti Trust Act should probably be amended to keep up with modern methods of communication

      1. Absolutely these tech giants should be broken up. But that will never happen under a Democrat Communist regime because these tech giants are working for the communists. Just like the MSM

    2. Patrician, it’s been said that Robert’s Adopted these kids for his Sexual needs? It’s also believed that he was on Jeffery Epstein’s Island, So I guess there are some questionable concerns whether he has compromising footage out there!!

    1. God bless him twice. He is also checking Biden’s “Executive Order gun ban”. It is illegal. That is a Congressional concern. Wonder how many of Biden’s EOs are illegal?

        1. Yes they sure should. Don’t let these evil people to do what they want to do. Make them earn what they are pushing.

      1. You cannot change an admendment it is against everything. I want to see him try. It will be the last thing they do before they see bars in front of there faces. Plz go ahead a try I dare you

          1. Not even an executive order can change it! It was meant to always remain. To change it would be considered treason…

  2. If big tech were censoring liberals instead of conservatives, they would be screaming racism at the top of their lungs.

  3. Better late then never I guess ..
    This should have already been addressed back in 2020 when they helped the libs steal the election.
    .

    1. I am so glad this is coming out. And I agree with The Georgia election laws put in place recently. We must not let evil win out. They are lying and cheating at every turn. Then they think they can do a gun grab. No, I don’t think so! The 2nd amendment is there for a reason. And it should be applied if the government gets too far out of hand.

      1. “IF THE GOVERNMENT GETS TOO FAR OUT OF HAND.” Where have you been living, in a cave? Biden’s 50+ EO’s are all “TOO FAR OUT OF HAND.”

        1. Likely if they start going door to door which would go badly for them when 100’s of armed citizens showup with the County Sheriff telling feds to get out fast while you can…!
          It won’t come to that as its illegal and they already know WON’T be tolerated by millions of us…!

  4. I sure wish the Supreme Court would do something about this administration ignoring the Constitution, especially the 2nd Amendment, Freedom of Speech, Separation of Government and Religion, and allowing illegals into our country and now planning to give them stimulus packages that are paid for by us, The People. This is so wrong.

    1. Yes I agree totally with free speech. I don’t want socialism or communism. We were not founded for that.

  5. YES! It’s time for SCOTUS to step on those Big Tech Companies and regulate their excessive actions!

    You Go Justice Thomas! Do it to them…finally!

    1. I agree except we know that it is not solely up to Justice Thomas. It is not a one man decision. A majority of the court would have to agree to consider the questions and getting that majority to do so may be difficult.

      1. The 2 females will be rendering damaging decisions for decades to come. I’m afraid Roberts will be as well.
        Judge Thomas is the man!!!!!

  6. Thank GOD we have a justice willing to stand against the forces working to take down our democracy. Thank you Justice Thomas😍

  7. Traitor,compromised, chief justice Roberts needs to resign, or be removed, for bad actions. on the court. The deep state, makes the decisions for this guy, he was compromised by the obuthead administration, he can’t be trusted after that incident with of phone call with liberal,judge Bryer.

    1. Roberts is a liberal rat. He must be eliminated from the bench.

      He is compromised and therefore, cannot render an unbiased decision.

      Why haven’t we found out who the “JOHN ROBERTS” was that showed up on the flight manifest of Jeffrey Epstiens airplane?

  8. Justice Thomas is an American hero deserving of great respect. Personally I would like to see the SCOTUS become more proactive, considering and ruling on questionable legislation and especially executive orders before they have to be challenged by plaintiffs at great legal expense and with extended windings through the judicial system.

    1. Judge Thomas is the most common sense, most reliable, even-keeled and knowledgeable justice conservatives have.
      He is my personal hero on the Supreme Court.

  9. All the Scotus need to go over these EO’s. seems like that is all Biden can do. Things worked when Trump was Pres. The Demos are so corrupt and change Culture via the hollywood elites is way out of control. THIS IS OUR COUNTRY too we have rights too. Biden wasnt elected by the people but by fraud. God help us. Hes ruining America

  10. LISTEN UP..The US. CONSTITUTION is Being TRAMPLED ON. Freedom of SPEECH Rights…GUN Rights…etc etc What is a SAMURAI Without Their SWORD???? MY SPIRIT Could NOT CAPTURE FALLEN ANGELS Without MY SWORD and REINFORCEMENTS. GOD Allows Freedom of SPEECH as Long as YOU Do NOT OFFEND HIM. From SamuraiQueen. 😄😄😄

  11. Judge Thomas is my personal hero!!!
    And rest assured, he has never forgotten the shameful, disgusting & uncalled-for personal attacks he received from democrats, particularly one Joe Biden, during his confirmation hearings for the Supreme Court.

  12. SO WHO IS THAT PERSON TALKING TO JUDGE THOMAS—– IS IT THAT SNAKE IN THE GRASS OBAMA’S BRENNON —— IS HE THREATENING OUR JUDGE THOMAS??????

    1. It may be an old photo because it kind of looks like John McCain…!! McCain was a Pit Viper, too…just like Brennan…!!

  13. Yes, the Supreme Court should address big tech’s anti-free-speech censorship, but I assume the more constitutionalist justices will have to force it over the political Chief Justice Roberts objection.

  14. Democrats are totalitarian and do not want free speech which is why unelected officials from Big Tech (Big Brother) are controlling speech to the extent that they’re shaping the narrative on all issues which need Constitutional representation. MSM and Big Tech support Marxists and destruction of the United States as a free nation, to the extent that a former Republican President is blocked from speaking on any of their Big Brother platforms.

  15. Big tech are the same type of people who owned slave’s they took away their voice then and they are trying to do it again. We have to boycott these creeps.

  16. Big tech should lose their legal protections altogether. They are, effectively, monopolies acting with the political power of government, itself. Therefore they should NOT have the protection against suits or even class-action suits for censorship. Additionally, public censorship is grossly anti American.

  17. Thank God for Supreme Court justice Clarence Thomas. I might add a graduate of Holy cross in Worcester mass. Good for Holy Cross to have such an alumnus. My granddaughter will graduate there in May. I am proud. Thank you Justice Thomas for your hard work on behalf of all conservatives. God Bless you and God Bless America.

  18. censorship is how the socialism/communism governments keep their people under control – tell them what you want them to know and delete the truth that doesn’t fit the
    political agenda

Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

By submitting this form, I hereby consent to TrumpTrainNews.com's Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, which permits TrumpTrainNews.com and its affiliates to contact me.